Question of a non muslim - need your help

[Shaam]

I was searching something on Google and found a link and there were a few questions posed by a non muslim.
I mailed that link to a IRF then i felt ashamed that even i am a muslim i should try to answer these questions.
I prayed Allah and tried it.
As I am illiterate and dont know anything i need your help to add verses and hadith and your comments questions wise here.

please dont wirte jazak Allah mashaAllah etc without reading it.

its a doc file and you can download it.

http://www.2shared.com/document/PC_YWh87/Dear_All.html


there i only answer according to small wisdom that Allah gave me.


Thanks and Regards

Hammad....

[nadia88]

really nice to see this

[Shaam]

hudd hai.

[Truth Reveals]

Kafi Dair Say Wait Kar Raha Hoon.. Downloading Option To Aahi Nahi Rahi..
Questions Kya Thay BTW?

[Shaam]

jo link hai is ko click karein bhai
jo window khulei gi us me ek beech mei rectangle hoga us me right per neechey likha hoga
save this file to you pc.
waha sei download karlo bhai.

[Truth Reveals]

Link Ko Hi Open Kiya Tha.. Magar Wo Kafi Dair Say Loading.. Ka Option Day Raha Tha..
Par Hogya Hay Ab.. Page Refresh Kiya Hay..

[Truth Reveals]

Mein Ap Ki Research Read Karkay Inshallah Reply Karonga.. Jazak'Allah

[Shaam]

ok bhai.........

[MUSAFIR]

sham babu ager ager wo Q ka ap thred bna letay to hum jeson K liay bhe asani ho jati. salman ki tarhan meray say bhe link nahi khol raha.

[MUSAFIR]

am w8ing gime chance 2 say U thanXx:. :wacko:

[Shaam]

yaar kar tou doo per bara hojaye ga
ok let me paste it

[Shaam]

Dear All,
First of All I would like to say you all Islamic way of greeting
Assalam Alaikum
(May All Mighty God’s Blessing and Peace on you all)


Dear fellow,
Its your right to put questions if is your mind without any bad intention for gaining the and knowing the truth. Allah says several times in Quran, that it is the book for wise people. And come, read and think about what is said.


I am not a scholar, just a simple muslim who believes in Allah and try to think whatever he says. Here I try to answer your questions and will be appreciated if you read it and read more about islam in the real books.
First of all to know what Islam is don’t look at what we muslim do. Look what is being said in Holy Scripture Quran and Sahih Hadith. Its so logical as to understand the working of any device you consult the manual and our manual is Quran and Sahih Hadith.



Q1. Why would God want his creation to not ask, questions, criticize, debate or experiment ideas that he gave us? This can only happen to cover up lies. This is the reason why we can’t question clergy about things like What’s the proof that God exists and what’s the proof that Muhammad is the prophet of God. Seems like a great deceit to make sheep out of humans. Only truth can stand the fierce scrutiny and criticism and still stand tall.

A1. Whenever your child try to do something which could harm him like touching electrical switches or try to eat or drink something bad you stop him and usually DON’T DO IT, IT WILL HARM YOU. Why? Simply because you know better then him. Allah is according to our belief is our creator and the creator of the whole universe he knows the functions and the kith and kins better then us. He never said don’t ask but don’t disobey because it is what is best for us. Its pretty common in army where asking question are prohibited because of the discipline because a senior knows better then a junior.
Now the second part is it possible that a tree comes from ground without a seed and then it become big and cut automatically and then its wood shaped itself a boat or a furniture ?
NO indeed…. Then how its possible that a huge flawless system is running and created without a God or a creator.
Muhammad (peace be upon him) is his last and true prophet because the creator said it. When we say “there is no god except Allah” it means we submitted our will to a much more powerful personality and bows ourself infront of him and then he said “ Muhammad is Prophet of Allah”.

I am working more on it and will send you more details as soon as I study as I said unfortunately I am not a scholar.




Q2. Why would God make religions appear only in poor, illiterate and desert areas? 1400 years ago, Greek were more scientific and progressive, why religion didn’t appear there instead? I tell you why. Because Muhammad could have only mislead the gullible, ignorant and poor people. In fact, his first followers were actually poor. Rich and literate people thought of him as crazy. Even today, if I go to a illiterate village and proclaim myself as a big saint, millions will follow me. That’s how easy it is to make stupid people more stupid. That’s why you don’t see new religions forming in Europe.


A2. It’s a general fact that the wealth made man think superior than others. And revolution always comes from poor people example French Revolution.
Yes, Greeks may be the most scientific people back 1400 years but tell me one thing if there are riots happening in two areas one where people using hand to fight and in other areas people using guns. Where you will send the police first ?
The rich people didn’t accept islam that easily because islam talks about equality of mankind, islams says no arab is superior then a non arab. The only criteria of becoming superior is good deeds. Allah does not discriminate it creature w.r.t wealth for him every human is equal. Now if a women has 2 children. One become rich and one is poor. Whom she will love more?
Would her love changes as per wealth or she will love more to that child who obey her more?
This theory of islam was unacceptable to the rich people. Because after accepting islam they have to sit with their slaves and offer prayer inline with them. They have to treat them as their brother.


Q3. If there is Science in Islam, why didn’t God tell us how old the Universe is, how old Earth is, whether it is round or flat, how long it took for it to cool down, how Life began, how Life evolved? It seems that Allah knew only things that were already known at that time by the Greek and ancient scientists and philosophers. If I start a religion today, I wouldn’t forget to add an ayat, “And thou will not spread mischief in the earth which took us fifteen billion years to make. There are altogether eleven dimensions, yet the unbelievers deny our signs.” Ridiculous!

A3. I would say that you must didn’t read Quran and messages behind the hadiths because in Quran there is everything about universe, earth, sun and moon. Even in Quran it is been said 1400 years ago for the dis believers that their skin will be burnt and then it will be remake then burn again, Now in last 50 60 years this is being proved that skin only feels the burning pain. The flash doesn’t feel anything due to fire. I would request you read Quran translation and think it.
It is being said by the prophet that sit before drinking water now science says yes this is the best way of drinking water
Prophet says say Alhumdullilah(Thankyou Allah), now science says that yes when we sneez our whole body resets even the heartbeats stop for a while. And after returning from that state we thanks To Allah.

For science in Quran I am pasting a link and you are requested kindly watch it whole.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XaI0niPwl5U
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_xtIyoqqsMA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HsnzZZ6WAzU
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUi1_K7Qxk4


Q4. Why Abrahamic religions, specifically Islam is exclusivist? How can a truth be confined to some people and not others (people living in other places, other times etc. can’t be all wrong). Buddhism on the other hand is not exclusivist like Islam. Buddha even said don’t believe me, don’t believe your holy books, don’t believe what people say, but believe only what’s true to your heart and mind, because truth can only come from inside, not outside (outside = scriptures, prophets, gods).

A4. Why don’t we ride on horses now, why don’t we use peigons for messeging, why don’t we use coal in engines or so many things. Its quite simple the technology and methods obsolete due to arrival of a better technology. Why not the commandments and religions if its true.
Look Brother, if I say that I am on the right path and u as well. we live in a social world. We have to interact and we have to do things mutually. Who will decide what the best way is.
A women in certain part of world do hijab, somewhere shake hands, somewhere hugs or kiss. Who will decide that what is right when there will be collaboration of civilizations ?
Budhism says look at your heart but tell me is every person has same capability of thinking ?
May be u are so good in realizing the truths and I am so dumb so I can not realize the real meaning of anything which is happening so don’t you think it will create some collapse?
Read Quran and think please.


Q5. Why would God care about whether people believe in him or not? The creator of the universes and each and every atom in them, can’t be so narrow minded, arrogant or stupid. Because arrogance means ‘covering up negative feelings about self’ and genuine God would rather be full of self-esteem than arrogance. God’s name being ‘Al-Mutakab-bir’ is beyond me.

A5. The definition of Allah in Quran

[
Say: He is Allah, the One and Only;
Allah, the Eternal, Absolute;
He begetteth not, nor is He begotten;
And there is none like unto Him.



And he aslo said that he created Man kind to worship him. He loves his people and he doesn’t want to punish them that’s why he says again and again to come to the righteous path. Why done we take example from our daily life. Why you want your child or your student to respect you ?
Now his name Al Mutakabbir because he is the one and only and the most powerfull.
If you have a very unique skills set you will be proud on you why not Allah when he created, he runs, He gives Life, he take life, he saves life. He has the right to be proud.








Q6. Why would God choose a mass murderer, rapist, blasphemer, pedophile, madman and power and sex hungry person as his prophet? Marriage with 9 year old Aisha, Marriage with his daughter-in-law Zainab, Marriage with Javairah, his slave after killing his father, husband and brother the same day, killing others just because they don’t believed him, killing someone if they change their religion, killing without reason, spreading Islam not with discussion, logic or spirituality but with murder and war is beyond me.


A5. Many of my muslim brother will abuse you when reading these words but I didn’t but I only request you that being a civilized person you should respect and don’t use such words which hurt any person. Islam don’t allow us to demolish the worship place of non-muslim in muslim territories and even its our faith and we can’t become a muslim without accepting that Jesus and Mosses were one of the greatest men in the history and Prophets of Allah.
If you abuse anybody’s parents he will definitely hit you or may be kill you and we love our Prophet more then our parents so please please please its not civilized to abuse someone’s loved ones if you don’t agreed on them.


Now your question,
Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) faught more then 100 battles and only 1000 men were died on both sides. Can you have any better example of one of the most great general of battle field?

Before answering your question let me show you the life of prophet. How he looks what he has been defined by people about his looks.

Muhammad (peace be upon him) was of a height a little above the average. He was of sturdy build with long muscular limbs and tapering fingers. The hair of his head was long and thick with some waves in them. His forehead was large and prominent, his eyelashes were long and thick, his nose was sloping, his mouth was somewhat large and his teeth were well set. His cheeks were spare and he had a pleasant smile. His eyes were large and black with a touch of brown. His beard was thick and at the time of his death, he had seventeen gray hairs in it. He had a thin line of fine hair over his neck and chest. He was fair of complexion and altogether was so handsome that Abu Bakr composed this couplet on him:
"as there is no darkness in the moonlit night so is Mustafa, the well-wisher, bright."
His gait was firm and he walked so fast that others found it difficult to keep pace with him. His face was genial but at times, when he was deep in thought, there there were long periods of silence, yet he always kept himself busy with something. He did not speak unnecessarily and what he said was always to the point and without any padding. At times he would make his meaning clear by slowly repeating what he had said. His laugh was mostly a smile. He kept his feelings under firm control - when annoyed, he would turn aside or keep silent, when pleased he would lower his eyes (Shamail Tirmizi).

Even our mother Aisha said “the princesses of eqypt cut their finger when saw joseph (peace be upon him) and for my husband people cut their throats.


Look Man, after having such appearance he married a 40 year old women Khatija at the age of 25 and never married till she died. (she died 25 years after marriage). Now if Muhammad (PBUH) had a loose character(God Forbid) he should married to another women in his young age and I challenge you cant find any true example that he had a relation with any other women during this period.
Now after that islam was propagating very fastly and women use to come to prophet for their problems and due to natural phenomena they were unable to ask and got his time that easily.
For this purpose He married several women and taught them islam as anyone’s wife can know her husband better then others.

Now our mother Aisha, According to the tradition of that time a girl married when she become adult and hence Aisha did. Why it is not acceptable for people as the tradition of old arab and they accept the pregnancy of a ten year old girl without marriage in UK or USA ?

Zainab, was the cousin of Prophet (daughter of her father’s sister). She belongs to the noble family of banu hashim and was married to a slave zaid who was an ADOPTED child of Prophet (PBUH). She herself ask prophet to get divorce from Zaid as she was not comfortable to live with a slave due to her family background. Now when she got divorced and according to the ancient arab they do not marry the widows and divorcees of their adopted sons and ISLAM allows that according to Allah. And to break this rule PROPHET MUHAMMAD was the first person to act accordingly.


Javaria, his father haris bin abi zaraar was a rich arab. He was a enemy of islam and he prepared an army to attack muslims. When Muhammad came to know this he asked his followers to prepare for a war and they proceed to the war-field. Our Mother Javeria was prisoned and came to prophet. His father came to Muhammad and said my daughter is a princess she cant be a slave. Muhammad replied why don’t we ask Javeria itself.
Javeria replied I want to live with Muhammad. And then he married her.
Now her father and brother was not killed at all but u know what muslims released all the prisoners of that war as they said we cant prison to those people who belongs to the family and tribe of prophet’s wife.
Even Aisha said about her “ I didn’t find a women more usefull for her tribe then Javeria”


I hope you are getting my answers.




Q7. Ali Sina says that Muhammad was a mentally sick person or what you call a narcissist having temporal lobe epilepsy. I watched a video on ‘Temporal Lobe Epilepsy’ on YouTube. It is a BBC documentary and the way it describes about the experiences of people with sensitive temporal lobe resembles exactly how Muhammad acted when he used to get revelations, sweating, feeling guilty and sad, feeling that he’ll go mad and that sort of thing. Furthermore, why an angle would make him feel so demonic and depressed is beyond me? Aren’t we humans supposed to experience something enlightening, happy and peaceful when such alleged experiences take place?

A5. if you are a rich man and from some source you come to know after you, your wife and your children will become poor and will be disgraced. Will you enjoy you current life.
My Prophets Muhammad loves his people and he knew from GOD that after him the people will leave the right path a bit and will commit sins and will be punished in this world and here after. This made him worried so much.
Even when Allah sent the angle of death Izrael to take the soul of Muhammad he asked izrael go and ask Allah what he will do with my Ummah ( people) after me. When Allah replied that I will take care of them then he allowed him to take his soul.
If you read hadith several times he cried and prayed for his people after him.
And even in Quran Allah says several times that Allah will rewards the believers with the best just to satisfy his Prophet.


Q8. Why shouldn’t we accept for others, laws and morals we deem perfect for ourselves. That’s the only measure of truth. If I speak truth, do good, be gentle, I would want the same to happen to all people. Following this logic, if a Muslim who becomes a Hindu should be killed, shouldn’t we teach these great laws to all other religions. Shouldn’t Hindus, Christians and Jews also kill people who become Muslims? Why not? If what we regard as moral and as truth, shouldn’t that be true to all others?

A7. yes we appreciate the good deeds in the people from any religion and please without any bad intention kindly let me know any of the commandment of Allah and act of Prophet which shows disgrace of mankind and people.
Even Quran says about prophet that he is sent to show the best behaviors.
Now, if a person has cancer patient and makes his body so good and attaractive will you say that ok u looks so good now be like this don’t go to the doctor.
Certainly not, you will say that your main problem is there its useless to make any body or anything.
Similar, when our believes are false how can we be stuck of good deeds.
A driver no matter how good he is driving if he come on wrong path he was called wrong.
A scientist who’s fundamentals are wrong no matter how much and how dedicate he is working on his research can’t get the right results

Think honestly don’t you read and saw people accepted islam then killed or like faced the brutal behavior even today world. If you really don’t know tell me I will show you the proofs.
Now if a person is in a prison and try to escape why the try to stop him first and then ordered to kill him? Simply he will go and spread crimes even more badly then before.
I hope you will understand.


Q9. It seems that Muhammad was not a nice man, I couldn’t find a single act of kindness from this person in the whole of Islam’s history. The only two stories of kindness were the story of Jew lady who used to throw garbage at prophet and he, at the time of her death came to visit her. And another incident about a young man who used to eat too much sugar and her mother requested Muhammad to ask him to stop it. He didn’t ask him to stop anything but later asked him to stop eating too much sugar because this time around he himself stopped eating too much sugar. Both of these stories are fables and are not found in Quran, Hadiths or the complete Islamic History. If I am wrong, find me any ayat or hadith matching these stories. I will not become apostate if you can tell me a single incident of kindness ever done by Muhammad. Remember, you can’t tell me about what Muhammad said to his followers about how to conduct life and be kind etc. I want his own personal acts of kindness only. Any Schmuck can ask others to do good and himself do otherwise.


A9. Well, now I am sure you didn’t read the life of Muhammad (PBUH). Let me tell you a few example for various aspect of life.

For domestic life prophet says “ The most better person amongst you is who is more nice and humble to their wives”

For Animals “When slaughter animal Prophet use a sharp knife as the animal wont feel more pain and died”
The Camel that he used was kept crying after his death and the died.


For plants Prophets says “ don’t break the green leaves unnecessarily as they all worship Allah” ( modern science says that plants can speak, listen and even cry)

For his enemy : when He triumph Makkah he announced you all are forgiven who ever accept islam or go in Kabba or closer their door or go to abu sufiyan house or who surrenders except a few persons and let me tell you one the those person was the killer of his own uncle HAMZA who killed and chew his heart. Now what he done with him do u know?

Wehshi, was the name of that person who killed Prophet’s uncle Hamza in war of UHAD. When he came to knew that Muhammad ruled the Makkah he covered his face and came to him and before uncovering him he said I accept islam and then show his face. Muhammad companion came forward to kill him but Muhammad (PBUH) said stop there.
Acceptance of islam sheltered him and for me it is better to accept islam then to kill him or anybody.

DO U HAVE ANY EXAMPLE SUCH THAT ?

THOSE ARE PEOPLE WHO HURT HIM SO MUCH. Who prisoned his family for three years and dint allow people to give them food and stuff easily. Those were people who tried to kill Muhammad several times and he forgave them
Even when he moved to tayif a place near makkah to preach islam. People of tayif hit him with stone and that much that his shoes filled with blood. Muhammad didn’t prayed god to kill them all but prayed that may God show them the right path.
And amongst those Tayif people there was Muhammad BIN QASIM who conquered sindh and islam entered in India.

Now some saying of Muhammad are
“Allah does not show mercy to those who does not treat his mankind with mercy”( it includes muslims and non muslims as well)

“One who a single innocent man is same as he killed the whole mankind and one who save a single innocent man life is same as he saved the whole mankind”

“Your mother is the most eligible of your mercy and then your father”

“The person is not amongst us whose neighbor harm from his tongue and hands”










Q10. Why a person who is religious is more prone to absurdities and away from reality of life? Why an educated person is less likely to be religious? Doesn’t that mean that religion is for the gullible, weak and immature? Why was Einstein, the most intelligent person who walked on earth was not religious. If it didn’t worked for him (most intelligent) How can you claim that you know better? If he worked it out without religion, why it won’t work for you?

A9. It is your observation and unfortunately if could be right for any other religion but not islam. I can show u doctors, engineering. Ph.Ds Scholars who practices islam much better then a illiterate person.
Even Quran says several times itself a book of wisdom for WISE people.

I told you previously why rich people didn’t accept islam that easily.











Q11. If God created us and sent Adam from Heaven to Earth, why are there fossils found for all early primates that were neither chimp nor humans? Checkout this link. What does God created something actually mean? Wherever science looks, it finds some process involved, no magic! Is God subjugated to natural laws? In our present lives we don’t see magic happening, no waters parted, no virgin births, no moons being cut and no back to the future Miraj happening. Humans have always attributed magical thinking to past and future events to make a sense of the world they live in. In other words, ‘I didn’t see it happen therefore magic man did it!’ Doesn’t it make sense?


A11. Kindly view comments of the link you gave above.
And just for the change of mood view this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6efxaviopI&feature=related
lolz
ok come the point.
The things you mentioned was miracles of several prophets and miracles cannot happened by common man otherwise what will be difference of a prophe and common man.
Now if we talk about process and procedures yes Allah says in Quran that we made everything in limits and they don’t cross their limits.
Allah made this universe very systematic. How come anything can happen without a system.
Theory of evolution proved wrong as DNA of anything does not change even after millions of year. View the link click here

And if miracles of Allah does not happens, can you explain a few things which are mentionedin Quran and remember Muhammad never went to those places. Like


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wa7Lqxzm9NE
and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sRH531JZEKI
and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G12K3y_BLtM
and kindly view the sequences.

The miracles you told was happened to told the world about the grateness of Allah.
Why don’t you think about an egg where no source of feed from mother and become a chick with blood and heart.(for man you can say that it takes feed from mother)
Why don’t you think about soil that from same soil we get thousand of different fruits and plants.
Why don’t you think about production of man where the chances of meeting X and Y chromosomes are almost ZERO but it combines and makes a man.
And so on
I would again request you that I am not a scholar and I really appreciate if you read quran your self and hadith and think.














Q12. If we have souls and are either to go to heaven or hell, why don’t animals have souls? Since we’ve evolved from animals, and early humans like homo erectus or homo habilis were intelligent too (slightly lower than us) would they also be judged on the judgment day? If not, why not? They didn’t have any prophets too, because their brains didn’t think in malignant ways like us. We are more clever. Doesn’t that prove that the more clever we get the more potential we have to become notorious and the most likely it is for a God to appear out of no where? (God didn’t made us in his own image, we made God in our own image).


A12. Who says that animal does not have soul ?
They do have and they will be presented in judgement day will be vanished after that and it is mention in Quran. Now why they don’t have prophet. What do you think why animals is being created.
Quran says they are created to serve you and that’s what we are doing with them.
Now we muslims don’t image our God as I mentioned you the definition of God that there is no one like HIM so if HE would be imaged he wont be a GOD. And we will accept anybody a GOD who can satisfy the definition mentioned above.


Q13. Buddhists are more moral than Muslims. They won’t burn embassies, temples and churches to prove they are true. They don’t believe in a God. Does it not mean that morality doesn’t depend upon God or absolute laws but inner resolve and commitment? Only immature and morally bankrupt people need fear of hell or greed of heaven to be moral.

A13. I said in the beginning don’t look at what muslims are doing. Look what they are said to do in Quran and Hadith.
Simply tell me can you justify the parents of 2 children that whos parents are better for society if one children is getting maximum marks and 1 is getting failed…. I hope you got the point.



Q14. If Quran is the Guidance from God, why can it be shaped in any way of thinking imaginable? A book of guidance from God should be straight forward and objective rather than being subjective and full of discrepancies. But it seems our Omniscient God thinks like humans and learns via trial and error.

A14. kindly mention the errors.
For the early part of the question I say that Quran was given as the best book in anyway. That time of Arab, they do not make any person kind till he cant be able to say verses. They had not made any person a messenger until he had a command over language. So Quran was sent in the best language that even Arab poets says it’s a magic.
One need to learn Arabian language to get the real magic of Quran. According to the new theory a language cannot be translate into other but can be transliterate.
View the link
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transliteration
so one cant get the real taste of sea going into the river.







Q15. If the only reason one should stick to religion is because of the uncertainties of the afterlife, what if it turned out that, there in fact is a God who tested us all to see whether we become fools at the hands of authority, religion and society or discover the truth and reality of life. All those who allow themselves to become fools may end up in hell and all those who turn to truth and reality are given heaven. Doesn’t it seem more rational for a thinking person to assume, by observing all the multitudes of religions in the world than to follow Islam?



A15. Why we work more harder without certainity that we will get the right fruit. And Why we work when we cant see that work returns money ?
Its faith my brother. The faith which keeps you wear warm cloth in winter even you see coldness.
The faith which keep you away from fire and electricity even you don’t see them calling u to harm you.
Its faith of our heart and mind which made us realize the existence of God….

In the end I would like to tell me that kindly read Quran itself and Hadith
And we muslims atleast 17 times a day says in our prayers that
“May we got the right path”
I hope you will also get the right Path.


In the end I would like to say that even if I couldn’t answer your even 1 question and I couldn’t proof anything about Allah and Muhammad still I believe that
“There is no body to worship but ALLAH and Muhammad is his True Messenger”


Thanks


Hammad S. Shamsi


Kindly contact me if you have any question in your mind.

[Shaam]

Dear All,
First of All I would like to say you all Islamic way of greeting
Assalam Alaikum
(May All Mighty God’s Blessing and Peace on you all)


Dear fellow,
Its your right to put questions if is your mind without any bad intention for gaining the and knowing the truth. Allah says several times in Quran, that it is the book for wise people. And come, read and think about what is said.


I am not a scholar, just a simple muslim who believes in Allah and try to think whatever he says. Here I try to answer your questions and will be appreciated if you read it and read more about islam in the real books.
First of all to know what Islam is don’t look at what we muslim do. Look what is being said in Holy Scripture Quran and Sahih Hadith. Its so logical as to understand the working of any device you consult the manual and our manual is Quran and Sahih Hadith.



Q1. Why would God want his creation to not ask, questions, criticize, debate or experiment ideas that he gave us? This can only happen to cover up lies. This is the reason why we can’t question clergy about things like What’s the proof that God exists and what’s the proof that Muhammad is the prophet of God. Seems like a great deceit to make sheep out of humans. Only truth can stand the fierce scrutiny and criticism and still stand tall.

A1. Whenever your child try to do something which could harm him like touching electrical switches or try to eat or drink something bad you stop him and usually DON’T DO IT, IT WILL HARM YOU. Why? Simply because you know better then him. Allah is according to our belief is our creator and the creator of the whole universe he knows the functions and the kith and kins better then us. He never said don’t ask but don’t disobey because it is what is best for us. Its pretty common in army where asking question are prohibited because of the discipline because a senior knows better then a junior.
Now the second part is it possible that a tree comes from ground without a seed and then it become big and cut automatically and then its wood shaped itself a boat or a furniture ?
NO indeed…. Then how its possible that a huge flawless system is running and created without a God or a creator.
Muhammad (peace be upon him) is his last and true prophet because the creator said it. When we say “there is no god except Allah” it means we submitted our will to a much more powerful personality and bows ourself infront of him and then he said “ Muhammad is Prophet of Allah”.

I am working more on it and will send you more details as soon as I study as I said unfortunately I am not a scholar.




Q2. Why would God make religions appear only in poor, illiterate and desert areas? 1400 years ago, Greek were more scientific and progressive, why religion didn’t appear there instead? I tell you why. Because Muhammad could have only mislead the gullible, ignorant and poor people. In fact, his first followers were actually poor. Rich and literate people thought of him as crazy. Even today, if I go to a illiterate village and proclaim myself as a big saint, millions will follow me. That’s how easy it is to make stupid people more stupid. That’s why you don’t see new religions forming in Europe.


A2. It’s a general fact that the wealth made man think superior than others. And revolution always comes from poor people example French Revolution.
Yes, Greeks may be the most scientific people back 1400 years but tell me one thing if there are riots happening in two areas one where people using hand to fight and in other areas people using guns. Where you will send the police first ?
The rich people didn’t accept islam that easily because islam talks about equality of mankind, islams says no arab is superior then a non arab. The only criteria of becoming superior is good deeds. Allah does not discriminate it creature w.r.t wealth for him every human is equal. Now if a women has 2 children. One become rich and one is poor. Whom she will love more?
Would her love changes as per wealth or she will love more to that child who obey her more?
This theory of islam was unacceptable to the rich people. Because after accepting islam they have to sit with their slaves and offer prayer inline with them. They have to treat them as their brother.


Q3. If there is Science in Islam, why didn’t God tell us how old the Universe is, how old Earth is, whether it is round or flat, how long it took for it to cool down, how Life began, how Life evolved? It seems that Allah knew only things that were already known at that time by the Greek and ancient scientists and philosophers. If I start a religion today, I wouldn’t forget to add an ayat, “And thou will not spread mischief in the earth which took us fifteen billion years to make. There are altogether eleven dimensions, yet the unbelievers deny our signs.” Ridiculous!

A3. I would say that you must didn’t read Quran and messages behind the hadiths because in Quran there is everything about universe, earth, sun and moon. Even in Quran it is been said 1400 years ago for the dis believers that their skin will be burnt and then it will be remake then burn again, Now in last 50 60 years this is being proved that skin only feels the burning pain. The flash doesn’t feel anything due to fire. I would request you read Quran translation and think it.
It is being said by the prophet that sit before drinking water now science says yes this is the best way of drinking water
Prophet says say Alhumdullilah(Thankyou Allah), now science says that yes when we sneez our whole body resets even the heartbeats stop for a while. And after returning from that state we thanks To Allah.

For science in Quran I am pasting a link and you are requested kindly watch it whole.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XaI0niPwl5U
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_xtIyoqqsMA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HsnzZZ6WAzU
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUi1_K7Qxk4


Q4. Why Abrahamic religions, specifically Islam is exclusivist? How can a truth be confined to some people and not others (people living in other places, other times etc. can’t be all wrong). Buddhism on the other hand is not exclusivist like Islam. Buddha even said don’t believe me, don’t believe your holy books, don’t believe what people say, but believe only what’s true to your heart and mind, because truth can only come from inside, not outside (outside = scriptures, prophets, gods).

A4. Why don’t we ride on horses now, why don’t we use peigons for messeging, why don’t we use coal in engines or so many things. Its quite simple the technology and methods obsolete due to arrival of a better technology. Why not the commandments and religions if its true.
Look Brother, if I say that I am on the right path and u as well. we live in a social world. We have to interact and we have to do things mutually. Who will decide what the best way is.
A women in certain part of world do hijab, somewhere shake hands, somewhere hugs or kiss. Who will decide that what is right when there will be collaboration of civilizations ?
Budhism says look at your heart but tell me is every person has same capability of thinking ?
May be u are so good in realizing the truths and I am so dumb so I can not realize the real meaning of anything which is happening so don’t you think it will create some collapse?
Read Quran and think please.


Q5. Why would God care about whether people believe in him or not? The creator of the universes and each and every atom in them, can’t be so narrow minded, arrogant or stupid. Because arrogance means ‘covering up negative feelings about self’ and genuine God would rather be full of self-esteem than arrogance. God’s name being ‘Al-Mutakab-bir’ is beyond me.

A5. The definition of Allah in Quran

[
Say: He is Allah, the One and Only;
Allah, the Eternal, Absolute;
He begetteth not, nor is He begotten;
And there is none like unto Him.



And he aslo said that he created Man kind to worship him. He loves his people and he doesn’t want to punish them that’s why he says again and again to come to the righteous path. Why done we take example from our daily life. Why you want your child or your student to respect you ?
Now his name Al Mutakabbir because he is the one and only and the most powerfull.
If you have a very unique skills set you will be proud on you why not Allah when he created, he runs, He gives Life, he take life, he saves life. He has the right to be proud.








Q6. Why would God choose a mass murderer, rapist, blasphemer, pedophile, madman and power and sex hungry person as his prophet? Marriage with 9 year old Aisha, Marriage with his daughter-in-law Zainab, Marriage with Javairah, his slave after killing his father, husband and brother the same day, killing others just because they don’t believed him, killing someone if they change their religion, killing without reason, spreading Islam not with discussion, logic or spirituality but with murder and war is beyond me.


A5. Many of my muslim brother will abuse you when reading these words but I didn’t but I only request you that being a civilized person you should respect and don’t use such words which hurt any person. Islam don’t allow us to demolish the worship place of non-muslim in muslim territories and even its our faith and we can’t become a muslim without accepting that Jesus and Mosses were one of the greatest men in the history and Prophets of Allah.
If you abuse anybody’s parents he will definitely hit you or may be kill you and we love our Prophet more then our parents so please please please its not civilized to abuse someone’s loved ones if you don’t agreed on them.


Now your question,
Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) faught more then 100 battles and only 1000 men were died on both sides. Can you have any better example of one of the most great general of battle field?

Before answering your question let me show you the life of prophet. How he looks what he has been defined by people about his looks.

Muhammad (peace be upon him) was of a height a little above the average. He was of sturdy build with long muscular limbs and tapering fingers. The hair of his head was long and thick with some waves in them. His forehead was large and prominent, his eyelashes were long and thick, his nose was sloping, his mouth was somewhat large and his teeth were well set. His cheeks were spare and he had a pleasant smile. His eyes were large and black with a touch of brown. His beard was thick and at the time of his death, he had seventeen gray hairs in it. He had a thin line of fine hair over his neck and chest. He was fair of complexion and altogether was so handsome that Abu Bakr composed this couplet on him:
"as there is no darkness in the moonlit night so is Mustafa, the well-wisher, bright."
His gait was firm and he walked so fast that others found it difficult to keep pace with him. His face was genial but at times, when he was deep in thought, there there were long periods of silence, yet he always kept himself busy with something. He did not speak unnecessarily and what he said was always to the point and without any padding. At times he would make his meaning clear by slowly repeating what he had said. His laugh was mostly a smile. He kept his feelings under firm control - when annoyed, he would turn aside or keep silent, when pleased he would lower his eyes (Shamail Tirmizi).

Even our mother Aisha said “the princesses of eqypt cut their finger when saw joseph (peace be upon him) and for my husband people cut their throats.


Look Man, after having such appearance he married a 40 year old women Khatija at the age of 25 and never married till she died. (she died 25 years after marriage). Now if Muhammad (PBUH) had a loose character(God Forbid) he should married to another women in his young age and I challenge you cant find any true example that he had a relation with any other women during this period.
Now after that islam was propagating very fastly and women use to come to prophet for their problems and due to natural phenomena they were unable to ask and got his time that easily.
For this purpose He married several women and taught them islam as anyone’s wife can know her husband better then others.

Now our mother Aisha, According to the tradition of that time a girl married when she become adult and hence Aisha did. Why it is not acceptable for people as the tradition of old arab and they accept the pregnancy of a ten year old girl without marriage in UK or USA ?

Zainab, was the cousin of Prophet (daughter of her father’s sister). She belongs to the noble family of banu hashim and was married to a slave zaid who was an ADOPTED child of Prophet (PBUH). She herself ask prophet to get divorce from Zaid as she was not comfortable to live with a slave due to her family background. Now when she got divorced and according to the ancient arab they do not marry the widows and divorcees of their adopted sons and ISLAM allows that according to Allah. And to break this rule PROPHET MUHAMMAD was the first person to act accordingly.


Javaria, his father haris bin abi zaraar was a rich arab. He was a enemy of islam and he prepared an army to attack muslims. When Muhammad came to know this he asked his followers to prepare for a war and they proceed to the war-field. Our Mother Javeria was prisoned and came to prophet. His father came to Muhammad and said my daughter is a princess she cant be a slave. Muhammad replied why don’t we ask Javeria itself.
Javeria replied I want to live with Muhammad. And then he married her.
Now her father and brother was not killed at all but u know what muslims released all the prisoners of that war as they said we cant prison to those people who belongs to the family and tribe of prophet’s wife.
Even Aisha said about her “ I didn’t find a women more usefull for her tribe then Javeria”


I hope you are getting my answers.




Q7. Ali Sina says that Muhammad was a mentally sick person or what you call a narcissist having temporal lobe epilepsy. I watched a video on ‘Temporal Lobe Epilepsy’ on YouTube. It is a BBC documentary and the way it describes about the experiences of people with sensitive temporal lobe resembles exactly how Muhammad acted when he used to get revelations, sweating, feeling guilty and sad, feeling that he’ll go mad and that sort of thing. Furthermore, why an angle would make him feel so demonic and depressed is beyond me? Aren’t we humans supposed to experience something enlightening, happy and peaceful when such alleged experiences take place?

A5. if you are a rich man and from some source you come to know after you, your wife and your children will become poor and will be disgraced. Will you enjoy you current life.
My Prophets Muhammad loves his people and he knew from GOD that after him the people will leave the right path a bit and will commit sins and will be punished in this world and here after. This made him worried so much.
Even when Allah sent the angle of death Izrael to take the soul of Muhammad he asked izrael go and ask Allah what he will do with my Ummah ( people) after me. When Allah replied that I will take care of them then he allowed him to take his soul.
If you read hadith several times he cried and prayed for his people after him.
And even in Quran Allah says several times that Allah will rewards the believers with the best just to satisfy his Prophet.


Q8. Why shouldn’t we accept for others, laws and morals we deem perfect for ourselves. That’s the only measure of truth. If I speak truth, do good, be gentle, I would want the same to happen to all people. Following this logic, if a Muslim who becomes a Hindu should be killed, shouldn’t we teach these great laws to all other religions. Shouldn’t Hindus, Christians and Jews also kill people who become Muslims? Why not? If what we regard as moral and as truth, shouldn’t that be true to all others?

A7. yes we appreciate the good deeds in the people from any religion and please without any bad intention kindly let me know any of the commandment of Allah and act of Prophet which shows disgrace of mankind and people.
Even Quran says about prophet that he is sent to show the best behaviors.
Now, if a person has cancer patient and makes his body so good and attaractive will you say that ok u looks so good now be like this don’t go to the doctor.
Certainly not, you will say that your main problem is there its useless to make any body or anything.
Similar, when our believes are false how can we be stuck of good deeds.
A driver no matter how good he is driving if he come on wrong path he was called wrong.
A scientist who’s fundamentals are wrong no matter how much and how dedicate he is working on his research can’t get the right results

Think honestly don’t you read and saw people accepted islam then killed or like faced the brutal behavior even today world. If you really don’t know tell me I will show you the proofs.
Now if a person is in a prison and try to escape why the try to stop him first and then ordered to kill him? Simply he will go and spread crimes even more badly then before.
I hope you will understand.


Q9. It seems that Muhammad was not a nice man, I couldn’t find a single act of kindness from this person in the whole of Islam’s history. The only two stories of kindness were the story of Jew lady who used to throw garbage at prophet and he, at the time of her death came to visit her. And another incident about a young man who used to eat too much sugar and her mother requested Muhammad to ask him to stop it. He didn’t ask him to stop anything but later asked him to stop eating too much sugar because this time around he himself stopped eating too much sugar. Both of these stories are fables and are not found in Quran, Hadiths or the complete Islamic History. If I am wrong, find me any ayat or hadith matching these stories. I will not become apostate if you can tell me a single incident of kindness ever done by Muhammad. Remember, you can’t tell me about what Muhammad said to his followers about how to conduct life and be kind etc. I want his own personal acts of kindness only. Any Schmuck can ask others to do good and himself do otherwise.


A9. Well, now I am sure you didn’t read the life of Muhammad (PBUH). Let me tell you a few example for various aspect of life.

For domestic life prophet says “ The most better person amongst you is who is more nice and humble to their wives”

For Animals “When slaughter animal Prophet use a sharp knife as the animal wont feel more pain and died”
The Camel that he used was kept crying after his death and the died.


For plants Prophets says “ don’t break the green leaves unnecessarily as they all worship Allah” ( modern science says that plants can speak, listen and even cry)

For his enemy : when He triumph Makkah he announced you all are forgiven who ever accept islam or go in Kabba or closer their door or go to abu sufiyan house or who surrenders except a few persons and let me tell you one the those person was the killer of his own uncle HAMZA who killed and chew his heart. Now what he done with him do u know?

Wehshi, was the name of that person who killed Prophet’s uncle Hamza in war of UHAD. When he came to knew that Muhammad ruled the Makkah he covered his face and came to him and before uncovering him he said I accept islam and then show his face. Muhammad companion came forward to kill him but Muhammad (PBUH) said stop there.
Acceptance of islam sheltered him and for me it is better to accept islam then to kill him or anybody.

DO U HAVE ANY EXAMPLE SUCH THAT ?

THOSE ARE PEOPLE WHO HURT HIM SO MUCH. Who prisoned his family for three years and dint allow people to give them food and stuff easily. Those were people who tried to kill Muhammad several times and he forgave them
Even when he moved to tayif a place near makkah to preach islam. People of tayif hit him with stone and that much that his shoes filled with blood. Muhammad didn’t prayed god to kill them all but prayed that may God show them the right path.
And amongst those Tayif people there was Muhammad BIN QASIM who conquered sindh and islam entered in India.

Now some saying of Muhammad are
“Allah does not show mercy to those who does not treat his mankind with mercy”( it includes muslims and non muslims as well)

“One who a single innocent man is same as he killed the whole mankind and one who save a single innocent man life is same as he saved the whole mankind”

“Your mother is the most eligible of your mercy and then your father”

“The person is not amongst us whose neighbor harm from his tongue and hands”










Q10. Why a person who is religious is more prone to absurdities and away from reality of life? Why an educated person is less likely to be religious? Doesn’t that mean that religion is for the gullible, weak and immature? Why was Einstein, the most intelligent person who walked on earth was not religious. If it didn’t worked for him (most intelligent) How can you claim that you know better? If he worked it out without religion, why it won’t work for you?

A9. It is your observation and unfortunately if could be right for any other religion but not islam. I can show u doctors, engineering. Ph.Ds Scholars who practices islam much better then a illiterate person.
Even Quran says several times itself a book of wisdom for WISE people.

I told you previously why rich people didn’t accept islam that easily.











Q11. If God created us and sent Adam from Heaven to Earth, why are there fossils found for all early primates that were neither chimp nor humans? Checkout this link. What does God created something actually mean? Wherever science looks, it finds some process involved, no magic! Is God subjugated to natural laws? In our present lives we don’t see magic happening, no waters parted, no virgin births, no moons being cut and no back to the future Miraj happening. Humans have always attributed magical thinking to past and future events to make a sense of the world they live in. In other words, ‘I didn’t see it happen therefore magic man did it!’ Doesn’t it make sense?


A11. Kindly view comments of the link you gave above.
And just for the change of mood view this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6efxaviopI&feature=related
lolz
ok come the point.
The things you mentioned was miracles of several prophets and miracles cannot happened by common man otherwise what will be difference of a prophe and common man.
Now if we talk about process and procedures yes Allah says in Quran that we made everything in limits and they don’t cross their limits.
Allah made this universe very systematic. How come anything can happen without a system.
Theory of evolution proved wrong as DNA of anything does not change even after millions of year. View the link click here

And if miracles of Allah does not happens, can you explain a few things which are mentionedin Quran and remember Muhammad never went to those places. Like


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wa7Lqxzm9NE
and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sRH531JZEKI
and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G12K3y_BLtM
and kindly view the sequences.

The miracles you told was happened to told the world about the grateness of Allah.
Why don’t you think about an egg where no source of feed from mother and become a chick with blood and heart.(for man you can say that it takes feed from mother)
Why don’t you think about soil that from same soil we get thousand of different fruits and plants.
Why don’t you think about production of man where the chances of meeting X and Y chromosomes are almost ZERO but it combines and makes a man.
And so on
I would again request you that I am not a scholar and I really appreciate if you read quran your self and hadith and think.














Q12. If we have souls and are either to go to heaven or hell, why don’t animals have souls? Since we’ve evolved from animals, and early humans like homo erectus or homo habilis were intelligent too (slightly lower than us) would they also be judged on the judgment day? If not, why not? They didn’t have any prophets too, because their brains didn’t think in malignant ways like us. We are more clever. Doesn’t that prove that the more clever we get the more potential we have to become notorious and the most likely it is for a God to appear out of no where? (God didn’t made us in his own image, we made God in our own image).


A12. Who says that animal does not have soul ?
They do have and they will be presented in judgement day will be vanished after that and it is mention in Quran. Now why they don’t have prophet. What do you think why animals is being created.
Quran says they are created to serve you and that’s what we are doing with them.
Now we muslims don’t image our God as I mentioned you the definition of God that there is no one like HIM so if HE would be imaged he wont be a GOD. And we will accept anybody a GOD who can satisfy the definition mentioned above.


Q13. Buddhists are more moral than Muslims. They won’t burn embassies, temples and churches to prove they are true. They don’t believe in a God. Does it not mean that morality doesn’t depend upon God or absolute laws but inner resolve and commitment? Only immature and morally bankrupt people need fear of hell or greed of heaven to be moral.

A13. I said in the beginning don’t look at what muslims are doing. Look what they are said to do in Quran and Hadith.
Simply tell me can you justify the parents of 2 children that whos parents are better for society if one children is getting maximum marks and 1 is getting failed…. I hope you got the point.



Q14. If Quran is the Guidance from God, why can it be shaped in any way of thinking imaginable? A book of guidance from God should be straight forward and objective rather than being subjective and full of discrepancies. But it seems our Omniscient God thinks like humans and learns via trial and error.

A14. kindly mention the errors.
For the early part of the question I say that Quran was given as the best book in anyway. That time of Arab, they do not make any person kind till he cant be able to say verses. They had not made any person a messenger until he had a command over language. So Quran was sent in the best language that even Arab poets says it’s a magic.
One need to learn Arabian language to get the real magic of Quran. According to the new theory a language cannot be translate into other but can be transliterate.
View the link
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transliteration
so one cant get the real taste of sea going into the river.







Q15. If the only reason one should stick to religion is because of the uncertainties of the afterlife, what if it turned out that, there in fact is a God who tested us all to see whether we become fools at the hands of authority, religion and society or discover the truth and reality of life. All those who allow themselves to become fools may end up in hell and all those who turn to truth and reality are given heaven. Doesn’t it seem more rational for a thinking person to assume, by observing all the multitudes of religions in the world than to follow Islam?



A15. Why we work more harder without certainity that we will get the right fruit. And Why we work when we cant see that work returns money ?
Its faith my brother. The faith which keeps you wear warm cloth in winter even you see coldness.
The faith which keep you away from fire and electricity even you don’t see them calling u to harm you.
Its faith of our heart and mind which made us realize the existence of God….

In the end I would like to tell me that kindly read Quran itself and Hadith
And we muslims atleast 17 times a day says in our prayers that
“May we got the right path”
I hope you will also get the right Path.


In the end I would like to say that even if I couldn’t answer your even 1 question and I couldn’t proof anything about Allah and Muhammad still I believe that
“There is no body to worship but ALLAH and Muhammad is his True Messenger”


Thanks


Hammad S. Shamsi


Kindly contact me if you have any question in your mind.

[MUSAFIR]

kab ho ga paste :sleeping:

[Shaam]

please note that the answer are my own words ... it could be wrong so Allah forgive me and kindly correct me whereever i am wrong.

[MUSAFIR]

oH thanxx agia let me search it

[Abewsha]

sham babu ager ager wo Q ka ap thred bna letay to hum jeson K liay bhe asani ho jati. salman ki tarhan meray say bhe link nahi khol raha.